Making Sense of Alzheimer’s is a creative space for people to understand the past, present and future of Alzheimer’s disease. It is an evolving forum, a gallery of ideas, a museum without walls.

Jonatha Brooke: Making Sense of Alzheimer’s Through a Musical Play

Jonatha Brooke sat down with Jason Karlawish, MD to talk about her new musical play, “My Mother Has 4 Noses,” and her mother, the poet Darren Stone Nelson.  Described by the New York Times as a “haunted and haunting play with music,” “My Mother Has 4 Noses” is Jonatha Brooke’s mother-daughter love story, recounting Ms. Nelson’s descent into dementia and her family’s creative and poignant ways of managing her illness.

From Jonatha Brooke’s blog at

Free Shipping

My mother had very distinct periods of obsession as Alzheimer’s slowly claimed her. As quickly as one had come and occupied, another would move in and take its place. To keep up, and to honor her changes, we would do our best to join her in each new “normal.” You can’t argue with Alzheimer’s.

For most of the fall of 2011, Mom was obsessed with the L. L. Bean Catalogue. She had lived for quite a while in Maine, and Maine IS L. L. Bean. Even when she was still living on her own, she’d jump at any excuse to make a whole day out of the trip to the L. L. Bean outlet store.

But that fall, – it was about a year after I’d moved her in with me in New York, – something about the neat pictures of slippers, stacks of flannel pajamas, 15 shades of pinpoint oxford shirts really reeled her in. The “free shipping” glowing from every page was the final ticket.

Anyone who came to see her got her pitch. “Now I want you to look through this L. L. Bean catalogue before you go. There are lots of sizes and colors, and… look…. FREE SHIPPING. Make sure you get whatever you need.”

She was very serious. So we went with it. Actually there was no alternative. She was on a mission!

My husband came up with the idea of creating order forms for her. Big type, orderly rows, simple choices. Mom was a poet and editor after all. Creating on her own had become too frustrating. But why not harness her instincts? She had latched on to these pretty pictures, the full pages of images and text, – no white space to fluster her. Nothing SHE had to compose. The order forms could be her new poetry.

Energized, mom spent hours and hours each day, working on her lists. She’d double and triple check with me, or Julie (my main caregiver, also my husband’s sister!) about whether we’d ordered yet. (One of mom’s enduring qualities was her concern that OTHERS be taken care of, whether it was having enough ice cream or a purple down vest) She would go to sleep in the evening, finally calm, comforted by this task well done.

We did order a bunch of things, but when the shipments actually arrived, she was unable to make the connection between what she’d done, and the new fleece-lined plaid shirt I was showing her. The whole joy was in filling in those order forms.

So we kept “ordering” – adding our wishes to hers. Everybody got in on it. My husband would ask her to order him some new slippers. The other caregivers were partial to the cashmere waffle hoodies. In November, one of her “real” poems was published in the “Christian Science Journal.” Amazing, as she hadn’t written anything new in over two years… but they’d found it in their archives of Darren Stone poetry. It was called “Genius.” I brought it to her in bed. She was having a cranky morning, and I thought seeing her name in print might raise her spirits. She rolled over slowly, looked at the tiny by-line set in glaring white space, and burst in to tears.


“Mom, what is it? I thought you’d love seeing your poem in the Journal. Published!” She was bereft: “But where are the sizes and colors? And I don’t see free shipping ANYWHERE.”

Jonatha Brooke has been writing songs, making records and touring since the early 90’s. After four major label releases, she started her own independent label, Bad Dog Records in 1999, and has since released seven more albums – her most recent, the companion CD to her critically acclaimed Off-Broadway show “My Mother Has Four Noses.”

Jonatha has recently co-written songs with Katy Perry for her new album PRISM, and with The Courtyard Hounds for their current release. She’s written for four Disney films, various television shows, and composed the theme song for Joss Whedon’s Dollhouse.

Ms. Brooke is also working on three other musical projects – Quadroon, with legendary contemporary jazz pianist Joe Sample; and Hopper and Death and Venice, with playwright Anton Dudley.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. AB says:

    I saw Jonatha’s play in Philly and was quite moved. Her interview on your website really drives home the idea of accepting and embracing the dementia patient’s sense of reality.

Not Alone

“Not Alone” was never meant to be made public when Gardner wrote it, but a powerful response from his mother encouraged Gardner to publish a formal music video to YouTube.

Portraits of Caregivers

Photographer Raymond W. Holman, Jr. captures the sometimes forgotten figures in the battle against Alzheimer’s disease dementia.

IOM Report on Cognitive Aging

The IOM Report on Cognitive Aging

Art of the Mind: Faye Hall Link
Art of the Mind

Faye Hall’s mother left notes for the trespassers stealing her food and moving her possessions, forgetting that these were her own actions. The artist used the notes as inspiration and as a medium in a portrait of her mother.

Beyond the Face of Alzheimer’s

“Beyond the Face of Alzheimer’s" - an intimate portrait of Alzheimer’s and related dementias.

I Am Life

Richard Rubin presents "I Am Life: Humanity In Advanced Dementia"


A daughter's honest graphic memoir of her mother's descent into dementia.

Building a Better Password

As people age, it can become even harder to remember the countless passwords used in daily life.

The Alzheimer Conundrum: Entanglements of Dementia and Aging

Listen to Jason Karlawish's review of Margaret Lock's book "The Alzheimer Conundrum."

Millennials Take Action: Designing to Preserve Dignity for Persons with Dementia

Creative young adults design innovations aimed at improving quality of life of patients and caregivers.

Art of the Mind: Greg Dunn Link

Greg Dunn spent years studying the human brain, only to spend countless additional hours trying to depict it in his art. Yet the neuroscientist-turned-artist says he is humbled by how much more complex the brain is than he could ever hope to show.

The Beginning Stages of Goodbye

Artist Alexandria Levin reflects on a cross-country train trip she took to help her mother, who has dementia, move into the final stages of her life.

Still We Dance: Artist Charles M. Williams
Slideshow and Video

Charles M. Williams combines his art with “the possibility of the ‘long good-bye’ that is Alzheimer’s.”

Should We Still Read ‘Still Alice’?

Jason Karlawish,MD explains why 'Still Alice' is not the right story to help us understand Alzheimer’s disease.

Making Sense of Alzheimer’s … A Student’s Perspective

A college student asks questions about Alzheimer’s disease to try and understand the complexity of the disease.

Hilarity for Charity Joins Fight Against Alzheimer’s Disease

Hilarity for Charity joins fight against Alzheimer’s disease.

Laughing with Dugald

Dramatists know the value of comic relief in the tragedy of life. Perhaps one man's own sense of humor is helping him to live with Alzheimer's.

History of Alzheimer’s Research

A walk through important dates in Alzheimer's disease research history.